Part XXI of the Constitution of India [Articles 369–392]: Temporary, Transitional and Special Provisions

Introduction

Part XXI of the Constitution of India, comprising Articles 369 to 392, deals with Temporary, Transitional, and Special Provisions. This part reflects the pragmatic and flexible approach adopted by the framers of the Constitution to address the diverse socio-political realities of India at the time of independence.

Unlike other parts of the Constitution, Part XXI is unique because it contains provisions that are not uniform in application. Instead, they are tailored to meet specific regional, historical, political, and administrative needs. Some provisions were meant to be temporary, while others continue to operate even today due to their ongoing relevance.

For UPSC Civil Services Examination aspirants, this section is crucial as it connects constitutional law with federalism, regional autonomy, and political integration of India.

Article 369 – Temporary Power of Parliament to Legislate on State List

Article 369 granted Parliament temporary authority (for five years from the commencement of the Constitution) to legislate on certain matters in the State List.

Key Features:

  • Applied to subjects like trade and commerce, production, supply, and distribution of essential commodities.
  • It was introduced due to the post-independence economic instability.
  • The objective was to ensure uniform control over critical resources during the early years of nation-building.

Significance:

Though temporary, Article 369 reflects how the Constitution allowed central intervention in state matters when national interest demanded.

Article 370 – Special Status of Jammu & Kashmir (Now Abrogated)

Article 370 provided special autonomy to the erstwhile state of Jammu & Kashmir.

Key Provisions:

  • Allowed the state to have its own Constitution.
  • Limited the legislative powers of Parliament over the state.
  • Required concurrence of the state government for applying central laws.

Recent Development:

  • In August 2019, through the Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 2019 and the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019, Article 370 was effectively abrogated.
  • The state was reorganized into two Union Territories: Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh.

UPSC Insight:

This is a highly important topic for both Prelims and Mains, especially in the context of federalism and constitutional flexibility.

Article 371 to 371J – Special Provisions for States

Articles 371 to 371J provide special provisions for various states based on their unique needs.

Article 371 – Maharashtra and Gujarat

Special responsibility of the Governor for:

  • Development of backward regions
  • Separate development boards

Article 371A – Nagaland

  • Protects:
    1. Religious and social practices
    2. Customary laws
    3. Ownership of land and resources
  • Central laws apply only with State Assembly’s consent.

Article 371B – Assam

  • Provision for a committee of tribal areas in the Legislative Assembly.

Article 371C – Manipur

  • Similar to Assam, focuses on tribal welfare committees.

Article 371D & 371E – Andhra Pradesh

  • Ensures equitable opportunities in public employment and education.
  • Establishment of a Central University in the state.

Article 371F – Sikkim

  • Ensures:
    1. Protection of existing laws
    2. Representation of different sections in Assembly
  • Important for integration of Sikkim into India (1975).

Article 371G – Mizoram

Similar to Nagaland:

  • Protects customary law
  • Land ownership rights

Article 371H – Arunachal Pradesh

  • Governor has special powers regarding law and order.

Article 371I – Goa

  • Deals with the size of the Legislative Assembly.

Article 371J – Karnataka (Hyderabad-Karnataka Region)

Provides:

  • Reservation in education and jobs
  • Development boards for backward regions

Significance of Articles 371–371J

  • Promote cooperative federalism
  • Address regional imbalances
  • Protect tribal identity and culture
  • Ensure inclusive development

Article 372 – Continuance of Existing Laws

  • All pre-Constitution laws remain in force unless altered or repealed.
  • Ensures legal continuity and administrative stability.

Importance:

Without this provision, India would have faced a legal vacuum in 1950.

Article 372A – Power of President to Adapt Laws

  • Allows the President to modify existing laws to align with the Constitution.

Article 373 – Preventive Detention

  • Authorizes the President to make orders regarding preventive detention during the transitional phase.

Article 374 – Provisions for Judges of Federal Court

Deals with:

  • Transition from the Federal Court of India to the Supreme Court of India.
  • Continuity of judicial proceedings.

Article 375 – Continuance of Existing Courts

  • All existing courts continue functioning under the Constitution.

Article 376 – Provisions for High Court Judges

  • Judges of pre-Constitution High Courts continue in office.

Article 377 – Comptroller and Auditor General

  • Continuance of the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India.

Article 378 – Public Service Commissions

Ensures continuity of:

  • Union Public Service Commission
  • State Public Service Commissions

Article 378A – Special Provision (Repealed)

  • This article has been repealed and is no longer in force.

Article 379–391 – Transitional Provisions

These articles deal with the transition from colonial governance to constitutional governance.

Key Areas Covered:

  • Formation of provisional Parliament
  • Election of the first President
  • Transition of legislative bodies
  • Adaptation of governance structures

These provisions ensured a smooth shift from British rule to democratic governance.

Article 392 – Power of the President to Remove Difficulties

Empowers the President to:

  • Remove any difficulties in implementing the Constitution.

Key Features:

  • Temporary in nature
  • Used during initial years of Constitution enforcement

Critical Analysis of Part XXI

1. Reflection of Cooperative Federalism

Part XXI acknowledges India’s diversity and provides asymmetrical federalism, where different states have different powers.

2. Tool for National Integration

Special provisions helped integrate regions like:

  • Sikkim
  • Nagaland
  • Mizoram

into the Indian Union while preserving their identity.

3. Flexibility of the Constitution

The inclusion of temporary and special provisions shows that the Constitution is a living document, adaptable to changing circumstances.

4. Criticism

  • Some argue that special provisions:
    1. Encourage regionalism
    2. Create inequality among states
  • However, others see them as necessary for unity in diversity.

Relevance for UPSC Civil Services Examination

Prelims Focus:

  • Article numbers and provisions (especially 370, 371 series)
  • Recent developments (abrogation of Article 370)

Mains Focus:

  • Federalism and asymmetry
  • National integration
  • Role of special provisions in governance

Answer Writing Tip:

Always link Part XXI with:

  • Cooperative federalism
  • Regional aspirations
  • Constitutional flexibility

Part XXI of the Constitution of India is a testament to the foresight of the framers who recognized that a diverse country like India cannot be governed through rigid uniformity. By incorporating temporary, transitional, and special provisions, the Constitution ensured both stability during transition and flexibility for future challenges.

From the temporary powers under Article 369 to the far-reaching implications of Article 370 and the nuanced provisions of Articles 371–371J, this part plays a critical role in shaping India’s federal structure and political unity.

For UPSC aspirants, mastering Part XXI is essential not only for exams but also for understanding the dynamic nature of Indian constitutionalism.

Visited 2 times, 1 visit(s) today

Discover more from UPSC Xplainer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.