Second Schedule of the Constitution of India – Salaries, Allowances and Privileges

The Second Schedule of the Constitution of India is a crucial yet often overlooked component of the constitutional framework. It lays down the provisions relating to the salaries, allowances, privileges, and emoluments of key constitutional authorities. For UPSC aspirants, understanding this schedule is important because it reflects the financial independence and dignity of constitutional offices, which is a key feature of democratic governance.

---

What is the Second Schedule?

The Second Schedule contains detailed provisions regarding the remuneration structure of high-ranking constitutional functionaries in India. These provisions ensure that such officials can perform their duties independently, without financial pressure or executive interference.

Originally, the Constitution provided fixed salaries in the Schedule itself. However, over time, many of these provisions have been amended, and salaries are now largely determined by Parliament through legislation.

---

Structure of the Second Schedule

The Second Schedule is divided into Parts A to H, each dealing with different constitutional authorities:

• Part A – President and Governors
• Part B – (Repealed)
• Part C – Speaker and Deputy Speaker of Lok Sabha; Chairman and Deputy Chairman of Rajya Sabha
• Part D – Judges of the Supreme Court
• Part E – Judges of the High Courts
• Part F – Comptroller and Auditor-General of India (CAG)
• Part G – (Repealed)
• Part H – (Added later – Union Public Service Commission members, etc.)

Let’s examine each part in detail.

---

Part A – Emoluments of the President and Governors

This part deals with the salaries, allowances, and privileges of:

• The President of India
• The Governors of States

Key Provisions:

• The President is entitled to official residence (Rashtrapati Bhavan) without payment of rent.
• The salary and allowances are determined by Parliament and are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India, ensuring independence.
• Governors are similarly entitled to official residences and allowances, charged on the Consolidated Fund of the State.

Importance:

This ensures that the executive head of the Union and States functions with dignity and independence, free from political or financial influence.

---

Part B – Repealed Provisions

Part B originally dealt with Rulers of Indian States (Privy Purses).

• These provisions were abolished by the 26th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1971.
• The amendment ended the system of privy purses and recognition of former princely rulers.

UPSC Insight:

This is an important topic linked with post-independence integration of princely states and constitutional evolution.

---

Part C – Salaries of Presiding Officers of Parliament

This part deals with:

• Speaker and Deputy Speaker of the Lok Sabha
• Chairman (Vice President of India) and Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha

Key Features:

• Salaries and allowances are determined by Parliament.
• These are also charged expenditures, ensuring independence from executive control.

Significance:

Presiding officers play a crucial role in maintaining parliamentary discipline and neutrality, and financial independence helps preserve their impartiality.

---

Part D – Salaries of Judges of the Supreme Court

This part provides for:

• Chief Justice of India (CJI)
• Other Judges of the Supreme Court

Key Provisions:

• Salaries are determined by Parliament (currently governed by the Supreme Court Judges (Salaries and Conditions of Service) Act).
• Salaries are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India.
• Judges are entitled to allowances, pensions, and privileges.

Importance:

• Ensures judicial independence, which is part of the Basic Structure Doctrine.
• Prevents undue influence from the executive or legislature.

---

Part E – Salaries of High Court Judges

This part deals with:

• Chief Justices and Judges of High Courts

Key Features:

• Salaries and conditions are similar in principle to Supreme Court judges.
• Paid from the Consolidated Fund of the State.
• Conditions cannot be altered to their disadvantage after appointment (except during Financial Emergency under Article 360).

Significance:

Maintains independence of the judiciary at the state level, crucial for federal balance.

---

Part F – Comptroller and Auditor-General of India (CAG)

This part provides for the salary and service conditions of the:

• Comptroller and Auditor-General of India (CAG)

Key Provisions:

• Salary and conditions are determined by Parliament.
• Expenditure is charged on the Consolidated Fund of India.
• The CAG is not eligible for further office under the Government after retirement.

Importance:

The CAG is the guardian of public finances, and independence is critical to ensure transparent auditing of government expenditure.

---

Part G – Repealed Provisions

Part G earlier dealt with certain provisions that have since been repealed through constitutional amendments.

---

Part H – Union Public Service Commission (UPSC)

This part includes provisions for:

• Chairman and Members of the Union Public Service Commission

Key Features:

• Salaries, allowances, and conditions of service are determined by Parliament.
• Expenses are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India.
• Members are barred from further employment under the Government (with limited exceptions).

Significance:

Ensures independence of the recruitment process for civil services, which is vital for a merit-based bureaucracy.

---

Key Features of the Second Schedule

1. Charged Expenditure

Most salaries under this schedule are charged on the Consolidated Fund, meaning:

• They are not subject to vote in Parliament or State Legislatures.
• This ensures financial autonomy.

2. Flexibility through Legislation

• Initially fixed in the Constitution, salaries are now mostly governed by statutory laws.
• This allows periodic revision without constitutional amendments.

3. Independence of Constitutional Authorities

• Ensures that key officials are free from executive or legislative pressure.

4. Constitutional Safeguards

• Conditions of service cannot be altered to the disadvantage of officials after appointment (with limited exceptions).

---

Amendments Related to the Second Schedule

Several constitutional amendments have impacted the Second Schedule:

• 26th Amendment Act, 1971 – Abolished Privy Purses (Part B)
• 54th Amendment Act, 1986 – Increased salaries of judges
• 97th & subsequent revisions (via legislation) – Updated salaries of constitutional authorities

---

Relevance for UPSC Civil Services Examination

Prelims:

Questions may be asked on:

• Which schedule deals with salaries of constitutional authorities?
• Which parts have been repealed?

Mains:

Analytical questions may include:

• “Discuss how financial independence ensures institutional autonomy.”
• “Evaluate the role of the Second Schedule in maintaining the dignity of constitutional offices.”

Interview:

Questions may relate to:

• Judicial independence
• Role of CAG and UPSC
• Constitutional safeguards for high offices

---

Critical Analysis

While the Second Schedule provides a robust framework, there are some issues:

Positives:

• Ensures independence and dignity of offices
• Protects against political interference
• Allows flexibility through legislation

Challenges:

• Frequent revisions via legislation may lead to political debates
• Public scrutiny over salary hikes of constitutional authorities
• Lack of awareness among citizens

---

The Second Schedule of the Constitution of India plays a foundational role in maintaining the independence, impartiality, and dignity of key constitutional authorities. By providing financial security and autonomy, it strengthens democratic institutions and upholds the rule of law.

For UPSC aspirants, a clear understanding of this schedule not only helps in static polity preparation but also builds a deeper appreciation of how constitutional mechanisms safeguard governance.

---